Toronto Fraud Charge Lawyer
Fraud cases are intricate, document-heavy, and turn on intent. With a background in finance and years in the courtroom, Robb MacDonald is equipped to dissect the evidence and build the defence the documents support.
Fraud under section 380 of the Criminal Code means depriving someone of money, property or a service by deceit, falsehood or other dishonest means. Over $5,000 it is an indictable offence with a maximum of 14 years. At $5,000 or less the maximum is two years. Over $1 million, prosecuted on indictment, carries a two-year minimum.
What counts as fraud under section 380?
Section 380(1) makes it an offence to defraud "the public or any person, whether ascertained or not, of any property, money or valuable security or any service" by "deceit, falsehood or other fraudulent means." The last phrase is what makes fraud so broad. A lie is not required. The Supreme Court has noted that courts treat using corporate funds for personal purposes, not disclosing important facts, exploiting another person's weakness, and diverting funds without authorization as "other fraudulent means."
In practice the charge reaches far. A false mortgage or loan application can be charged as fraud. So can an insurance claim the Crown says was knowingly inflated. Employees are charged over their employer's funds, sellers over goods that never shipped, and promoters over investments and charities that turned out to be something else. Tax schemes can be prosecuted as fraud under the Code too. A separate subsection, s. 380(2), covers fraudulently affecting the public market price of stocks, shares or goods, with the same 14-year maximum.
One point of clarity. If you believe you are the victim of a fraud, your first call should be to the police or to a civil lawyer, not to criminal defence counsel. Robb's work is defending people who are accused.
What does the Crown have to prove?
The leading case is R. v. Théroux, [1993] 2 SCR 5. The Supreme Court of Canada held that the Crown must prove two things about the conduct and two things about the accused's state of mind, all beyond a reasonable doubt:
- A dishonest act: deceit, a falsehood, or some other fraudulent means.
- Deprivation caused by that act: an actual loss, or the placing of the victim's financial interests at risk.
- Knowledge of the act: the accused knew they were doing the thing that was dishonest.
- Knowledge of the consequence: the accused knew the act could deprive someone, which includes knowing it put their financial interests at risk.
Two things follow. A loss does not have to occur; putting someone's money at risk is enough. And the Court said that a belief that the conduct was not wrong, or that no one would be hurt in the end, is no defence. What is a defence is the absence of dishonesty itself: a genuine belief in the facts, a real business dispute, an honest mistake, or someone else's conduct being attributed to you. That is why intent is so often where fraud cases are won or lost.
What is the difference between fraud over and under $5,000?
The dollar line changes almost everything about the case.
Fraud over $5,000 (or fraud involving a will or other testamentary instrument, at any value) is a straight indictable offence under s. 380(1)(a), with a maximum of 14 years. Because the maximum is 14 years, the accused can choose how to be tried: by a judge of the Ontario Court of Justice, by a judge of the Superior Court alone, or by a judge and jury. The accused can also request a preliminary inquiry, which s. 535 now limits to offences punishable by 14 years or more.
Fraud of $5,000 or less is a hybrid offence under s. 380(1)(b). The Crown chooses whether to proceed summarily or by indictment. On indictment the maximum is two years. Summarily, the general limit in s. 787 applies: up to two years less a day, a fine of up to $5,000, or both. Either way the case stays in the Ontario Court of Justice, because s. 553 gives that court absolute jurisdiction over fraud where the value does not exceed $5,000. There is no jury and no preliminary inquiry.
The value is the value of the subject matter alleged, and it is often disputed. Whether a series of transactions is charged as one count or many, and what each is worth, can move a case across the line. Our article on fraud over and under $5,000 in Ontario walks through the two tracks in more detail.
Can you go to jail for fraud?
Yes. Jail is a real possibility, particularly in larger frauds, but it is not automatic, and the range of sentences is wide.
- Maximums. 14 years for fraud over $5,000; two years on indictment or two years less a day summarily for fraud of $5,000 or less.
- The mandatory minimum. Under s. 380(1.1), when the Crown proceeds by indictment and the total value of the fraud offences exceeds $1 million, the court must impose at least two years.
- Discharges. A conditional or absolute discharge under s. 730 leaves no conviction, but it is not available for an offence punishable by 14 years. It is therefore not available for fraud over $5,000, and it is available for fraud of $5,000 or less.
- Conditional sentences. A sentence of less than two years can be served in the community under s. 742.1 if the court is satisfied it would not endanger the community and fits the principles of sentencing. The Bail and Sentencing Reform Act amended that section in July 2026 by excluding further sexual offences. Fraud is not on the excluded list, so a conditional sentence remains available unless the $1 million minimum applies.
What makes a fraud sentence heavier?
Parliament has written aggravating factors specific to fraud into s. 380.1. The court must treat each of these as aggravating where it is proven:
- The magnitude, complexity, duration or degree of planning was significant.
- The offence affected, or could have affected, the stability of the Canadian economy, the financial system, a financial market, or investor confidence.
- There were a large number of victims.
- The offence had a significant impact on victims given their age, health and financial situation.
- The offender took advantage of the high regard in which they were held in the community.
- The offender did not comply with a licensing requirement or professional standard that normally applies.
- The offender concealed or destroyed records of the fraud or of where the money went.
Section 380.1(2) adds a rule that surprises many professionals: the court cannot treat the offender's employment, skills, status or reputation as mitigating if those were relevant to, contributed to, or were used in committing the offence. The general sentencing provision, s. 718.2, also treats abuse of a position of trust or authority as aggravating, which is often the central issue when an employee or bookkeeper is charged.
Mitigating factors still matter, and they are what a sentencing hearing is built around: a guilty plea, a clean record, genuine remorse, repayment, the circumstances that led to the offence, and the collateral consequences already suffered.
Will I have to pay the money back?
Very likely, if there is a finding of guilt. Under s. 737.1 the sentencing court must consider making a restitution order, and must ask the Crown whether victims were given a chance to say they are seeking one. Under s. 738 the order can cover the value of lost property where the amount is readily ascertainable, and in identity theft and identity fraud cases it can cover a victim's reasonable costs of re-establishing their identity and correcting their credit.
Three related rules are worth knowing. The offender's inability to pay does not prevent the order (s. 739.1). Where the court is also considering a fine and the person cannot pay both, restitution comes first (s. 740). And an unpaid restitution order can be filed and enforced as a civil judgment (s. 741), so it does not disappear when the criminal case ends. Repayment made before sentencing is something defence counsel can put before the court.
Victims can also file a victim impact statement describing their financial loss and its effect on them, which the court must consider (s. 722). In frauds that affected a whole group, such as investors or a congregation, a community impact statement can be filed as well (s. 722.2).
What is a fraud prohibition order?
Under s. 380.2, a court sentencing someone for fraud, or granting a conditional discharge, can prohibit them from seeking, obtaining or continuing any employment, or volunteering in any capacity, that involves authority over another person's real property, money or valuable security. The court sets the length, which can be any period it considers appropriate. Breaching the order is a separate offence. For anyone who works in finance, bookkeeping, real estate, property management or a charity, this order can matter as much as the sentence itself.
What related charges come with fraud?
Fraud charges rarely travel alone. These are the ones most often laid alongside it:
- Identity theft (s. 402.2): obtaining or possessing another person's identity information intending to use it for an offence involving fraud, deceit or falsehood, or trafficking in that information. Maximum five years.
- Identity fraud (s. 403): fraudulently impersonating a living or dead person to gain an advantage, obtain property, cause a disadvantage, or avoid arrest. Maximum 10 years.
- Credit card offences (s. 342): stealing, forging or falsifying a card, using a card known to be stolen, forged or cancelled, and possessing or using card data without right. Maximum 10 years.
- Theft, possession of property obtained by crime, forgery and uttering a forged document, and false pretences. Theft and fraud overlap, and the Crown sometimes charges both. See our page on theft and property crime charges.
Identity theft, identity fraud and the credit card offences are all hybrid, so the Crown's election shapes the maximum and the court, in the same way as fraud under $5,000.
What are the common defences to a fraud charge?
There is no template. The right defence depends on the documents, and in a fraud case the documents are usually voluminous. These are the issues that most often decide the outcome:
- No dishonesty. A business deal that failed, a loan that could not be repaid, or a dispute over what was agreed is not a crime. Many fraud charges are civil disputes that someone took to the police.
- No knowledge. The Crown must prove subjective knowledge. A person who processed transactions on instructions, or whose account or identity was used by someone else, may not have known.
- Identity. In online and card cases, who was actually at the keyboard, or holding the card, is often the weakest part of the Crown's case.
- Value. Whether the amount is above or below $5,000, or above $1 million, changes the charge, the court and the sentencing range. Forensic review of the numbers can move a case.
- The Charter. Fraud investigations rely on production orders for bank records, searches of phones and computers, and statements. Evidence gathered in breach of section 8 or section 10(b) can be excluded.
- Delay. Large-document cases take time. Since July 2026, a stay of proceedings for unreasonable delay is available only if no other remedy would be appropriate and just (s. 492.31), and the court must weigh the complexity of the case (s. 492.26). Delay arguments are still worth making, but they are harder to win than they were.
How does a fraud record affect work and travel?
A fraud conviction is a conviction for dishonesty, and employers, licensing bodies and border officers read it that way.
- Work. Jobs in banking, accounting, insurance, real estate and anything requiring bonding or a background check are the most exposed, and a s. 380.2 order can bar a role outright. Regulated professionals may face a separate discipline process.
- Travel to the United States. US immigration law bars entry for a crime involving moral turpitude, and the US State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual treats crimes with an element of fraud as involving moral turpitude. A waiver may be needed. US entry is a matter of US law, so get advice from a US immigration lawyer before travelling.
- Immigration status in Canada. A permanent resident or foreign national convicted of an offence with a maximum of 10 years or more is inadmissible for serious criminality under s. 36 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. Fraud over $5,000, with its 14-year maximum, meets that test whatever the sentence. Non-citizens should raise this before any plea discussion.
- Clearing the record. A record suspension can be applied for five years after the sentence is completed for a summary conviction, and ten years for an indictable one under s. 4 of the Criminal Records Act.
Our record suspension guide explains how to apply once the waiting period has passed.
These consequences are the reason a discharge, a withdrawal, or a plea to a lesser or different offence can be worth more to a client than a shorter sentence.
What should I do if I am being investigated for fraud?
Fraud cases often start before any police involvement, with an internal audit, a bank's investigation, or an insurer's examination. Statements made at that stage are routinely handed to police. Get legal advice before you explain yourself to anyone investigating you. You have the right to remain silent with police and the right to a lawyer. Keep your own records, do not destroy or alter anything, and do not contact the complainant or witnesses about the allegation. If a charge is laid, the release conditions will often restrict contact and financial dealings, and our page on bail hearings explains how those conditions are set.
How Robb approaches a fraud defence
Robb MacDonald has practised criminal defence for more than 20 years and brings both legal experience and financial insight to fraud files. His approach typically includes:
- Case evaluation and evidence review: a thorough examination of the financial records, communications and documents to find inconsistencies and gaps in the Crown's theory, working alongside forensic accountants where the case demands it.
- Resolution discussions: where it serves the client, working with the Crown toward a withdrawal, a reduced charge, or a resolution that limits the consequences for work and travel.
- Trial: careful courtroom advocacy that tests the documents and the witnesses and holds the Crown to its burden of proof.
Past outcomes in other areas are on the case results page, and the stages of a criminal case are set out in our judicial process guide. If you are facing a fraud charge in Toronto, or expect one, call (416) 315-1505. Consultations are free and confidential.
Fraud Charges: Common Questions
Can you go to jail for fraud over $5,000?+
What is the maximum sentence for fraud in Canada?+
Is there a mandatory minimum sentence for fraud?+
Can I get a discharge for fraud?+
Will the charge be dropped if I pay the money back?+
What is the difference between fraud and theft?+
What is identity theft under the Criminal Code?+
Will a fraud conviction stop me from entering the United States?+
Should I talk to the police or my employer's investigators?+
Charged with fraud? Act now.
Robb is available day and night and in court five days a week. Free, confidential consultation.